11-02-2026 22:15
William Slosse
Today, February 11, 2026, we found the following R
11-02-2026 19:28
Lothar Krieglsteiner
on small deciduous twig on the ground in forest wi
25-04-2025 17:24
Stefan BlaserHi everybody, This collection was collected by JÃ
10-02-2026 17:42
Bernard CLESSE
Bonjour à toutes et tous,Pourriez-vous me donner
10-02-2026 18:54
Erik Van DijkDoes anyone has an idea what fungus species this m
09-02-2026 20:10
Lothar Krieglsteiner
The first 6 tables show surely one species with 2
09-02-2026 14:46
Anna KlosGoedemiddag, Op donderdag 5 februari vonden we ti
02-02-2026 21:46
Margot en Geert VullingsOn a barkless poplar branch, we found hairy discs
Hallo forum,recently I read an interesting article about taxonomy and one of the main topics was the criticism of those widely employed phylogenetic trees. The authors' argument was, that these trees are always dichotomous by design and thus cannot reflect the reality of different and divergent evolutionary branches in the nature. As probably everyone here, I'm familiar with Korf's article about dichotomous vs. synoptic keys, so from this point of view their reasoning looked good to me. I wondered if there's been any polemic with this article and I was rather surprised, when I didn't find any reaction / citation at all. But I hope I must have overlooked some sources and perhaps someone here would have a tip on a follow-up or related article?
Also, if anyone has Vasilyeva's book Systematics in mycology (1999) in digital version, I would be much interested.
Thank you in advance.
Viktorie
The first (and newest) article sums up both previous.
Vasilyeva LN, Stephenson S (2013): "I have come to some conclusions that shock me...". Mycosystema 32(3): 321-329. Online here, third article from the top: http://manu40.magtech.com.cn/Jwxb/EN/volumn/volumn_1283.shtml
Vasilyeva LN, Stephenson S (2012): The Hierarchy and Combinatorial Space of Characters in Evolutionary Systematics. Botanica Pacifica 1(1): 21-30.
Vasilyeva LN, Stephenson S (2010): The problems of traditional and phylogenetic taxonomy of fungi. Mycosphere 1: 45-51.